Build Your Own

Six pints. Your call.

Mix and match any six pints from our current lineup. One flat $85, packed with dry ice, shipped to your door.

  1. 1Pick
  2. 2Pack
  3. 3Ship
  • Superman ice cream
    Sometimes

    Superman

    A Michigan classic, created by the Stroh's Brewery during prohibition. This fun ice cream is a co...

  • Cherry Pie a la Booze ice cream
    Sometimes

    Cherry Pie a la Booze

    Amaretto pairs beautifully with a Julian cherry pie, so we created an amaretto ice cream with chu...

  • I'm Your Huckleberry ice cream
    Sometimes

    I'm Your Huckleberry

    You may have encountered the huckleberry before. Similar to the blueberry, and equally tasty. We ...

  • Caramel Apple Pie ice cream
    Sometimes

    Caramel Apple Pie

    Apple pies straight from the best source in California, the Julian Pie Company. We add notes of c...

  • Banana Pudding ice cream
    Sometimes

    Banana Pudding

    It's bananas, a lot of bananas, we infuse them into our creamy base. Add a bit of vanilla, and gl...

  • Deconstructed Snickers ice cream
    Sometimes

    Deconstructed Snickers

    Is there a better candy bar than a Snickers? This is an elevated take on that all-time classic. N...

  • Coffee, Toffee, & What? ice cream
    Sometimes

    Coffee, Toffee, & What?

    Are we crazy or crazy genius for this combination? Smooth coffee ice cream with a house made pret...

  • Last tub Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake ice cream
    Sometimes

    Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake

    This one was an instant classic. Everything great about pumpkin pie, the pumpkin, the spice, the ...

    Last tub — going fast.
    1 left.
  • Salty Santa ice cream
    Sometimes

    Salty Santa

    Even Santa can get a little grumpy at this time of year. Salty pretzels, covered with white choco...

  • Tiki Room ice cream
    Hold the Cow

    Tiki Room

    Any Disney fans here? This one will remind you of a certain favorite pineapple treat. Great pinea...

  • Candy Cane ice cream
    Sometimes

    Candy Cane

    Creamy, peppermint ice cream with a sizable dose of crushed up candy canes. No holiday is complet...

  • SOLD OUT Apple Sticky Bun ice cream
    Sometimes

    Apple Sticky Bun

    Cinnamon bun ice cream with apple pie filling and a cinnamon brown sugar swirl. Contains: Milk

  • Irish Coffee ice cream
    Sometimes

    Irish Coffee

    Our owner Chris used to bartend back in the 90’s and made a lot of Irish Coffees. Super creamy co...

  • Sometimes

    Banana Bread Latte

    Banana and coffee ice cream with hints of brown butter, brown sugar, and cinnamon.

  • SOLD OUT Be My Frankenstein ice cream
    Sometimes

    Be My Frankenstein

    If you like Halloween candy as much as we do, then this one is for you. Our absolute best ice cre...

  • Blue Moon ice cream
    Always

    Blue Moon

    Our founder, Chris, grew up in Michigan, where Blue Moon can be found in every creamery in the st...

  • SOLD OUT Butter Pecan 2.0 ice cream
    Sometimes

    Butter Pecan 2.0

    We wanted to challenge ourselves to a refreshed take on an all-time classic in butter pecan. Clas...

  • 🏅Award-Winning Chocolate Covered Strawberry ice cream
    Always

    Chocolate Covered Strawberry

    The darlings of the ball, our award-winning strawberry ice cream & Milk Chocolate Chunks, are now...

  • Cider Time ice cream
    Sometimes

    Cider Time

    Visiting the local cider mill for fresh cider and donuts is must do in the midwest. We infuse our...

  • Cookies in Cream ice cream
    Always

    Cookies in Cream

    Just like sitting down to eat a sleeve of these with a glass of milk, but beeeettttter! Some say ...

  • Hold the Cow

    Cookies in Milk-Less Cream

    Our amazing cookies in cream just made without that pesky milk. Super creamy, super tasty, this o...

  • 🏅Award-Winning FTW Chocolate ice cream
    Always

    FTW Chocolate

    Having lived in 4 countries and traveling often, chocolate is important to us. Like, REALLY impor...

  • Kentucky Bourbon Derby Pie ice cream
    Sometimes

    Kentucky Bourbon Derby Pie

    This is a pie that deserves to be more popular so we are making our own version to bring some fan...

  • Matcha Mochi ice cream
    Sometimes

    Matcha Mochi

    Beautiful matcha green tea ice cream is already good. Throw in delicious little mochi bites to gi...

  • Mint Chocolate Chunk ice cream
    Always

    Mint Chocolate Chunk

    Chunka Chunka burning love!!! With natural mint, chunky rich chocolate chunks, and zero artificia...

  • SOLD OUT No Cows Were Used in This Vanilla ice cream
    Hold the Cow

    No Cows Were Used in This Vanilla

    An impossibly smooth and creamy 100% plant based vanilla ice cream.

  • 🏅Award-Winning Old Reliable ice cream
    Always

    Old Reliable

    Reliably the safest choice, but not easy to get right. We use pure Madagascar vanilla for the bes...

  • Sometimes

    PB Maple Latte

    Peanut butter and maple balanced with our coffee ice cream, then we kick it up a notch by adding ...

  • Perfect PBC ice cream
    Always

    Perfect PBC

    Is there a better combo than chocolate and peanut butter? A chocolate and peanut-butter base with...

  • Root Beer Fudge Cake ice cream
    Sometimes

    Root Beer Fudge Cake

    Chocolate cake soaked in Root Beer, in the form of ice cream. Throw in a swirl of fudge and you h...

  • SOLD OUT
    Sometimes

    Rye & Apple Cake

    We have done a lot with Bourbon but not much with it's slightly spicier cousin, rye whiskey. We p...

  • SOLD OUTLast tub S'mores 2.0 ice cream
    Sometimes

    S'mores 2.0

    Can we make something better? Always. S'mores 2.0 is here with richer more delicious flavors. Roa...

    Last tub — going fast.
    1 left.
  • Speculitious ice cream
    Sometimes

    Speculitious

    We obsess over these wonderful European speculoos cookies, and this takes it up a notch. Cookie b...

  • SOLD OUT THAT Cookie Dough ice cream
    Always

    THAT Cookie Dough

    Everyone loves cookie dough, but it's what is hugging the cookie dough that makes it stand out. H...

  • Vegan Coconut Cake Batter ice cream
    Hold the Cow

    Vegan Coconut Cake Batter

    Our super creamy coconut base and gluten free cake batter. Tastes just like a moist cake coated i...

  • SOLD OUT Vegan Coconut Ube ice cream
    Hold the Cow

    Vegan Coconut Ube

    Ube is a wonderful purple root vegetable from Asia. A lot of people describe the flavor different...

  • SOLD OUTLast tub Wizard's Buttery Brew ice cream
    Sometimes

    Wizard's Buttery Brew

    A creamy, butterscotch and vanilla ice cream, rippled with a butterscotch swirl. We hear eating t...

    Last tub — going fast.
    1 left.